Who Did It Better

Marvin OR Chaka?

What's Going On

Written by Marvin Gaye, Renaldo Benson, Al Cleveland

Mother, mother
There's too many of you crying

What's this song about ↓

A question posed to a nation, a cry of confusion and pain from a man watching the world fall apart around him. Marvin Gaye recorded it as the centerpiece of his landmark album, a song that asked the hardest questions without pretending to have easy answers. What's going on? The question is genuine, bewildered, the sound of a man who cannot understand why the world refuses to learn from its mistakes.

That same question gets a funk-infused reading from

Original or Cover

The Original -- 1971

Marvin Gaye

Marvin Gaye
Floating Player

The Cover -- 2002

Chaka Khan

Chaka Khan
Floating Player
The Sunday Drop
One song. One story. Every Sunday.

No algorithms. No trending sections. Just a song someone loved and the story behind it. Delivered Sunday morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Image Credits

1,414 artist portraits across 5 genres (Rock, Jazz, Soul, Blues, Folk). 1,363 sourced from Wikipedia (Creative Commons / Public Domain), 50 from Deezer (promotional artwork).

Full attribution breakdown →

Who Did It Better

Marvin OR Chaka?

What's Going On

Written by Marvin Gaye, Renaldo Benson, Al Cleveland

Mother, mother
There's too many of you crying

What's this song about ↓

A question posed to a nation, a cry of confusion and pain from a man watching the world fall apart around him. Marvin Gaye recorded it as the centerpiece of his landmark album, a song that asked the hardest questions without pretending to have easy answers. What's going on? The question is genuine, bewildered, the sound of a man who cannot understand why the world refuses to learn from its mistakes.

That same question gets a funk-infused reading from

Marvin or Chaka
Chaka Khan in her 2002 version. Where Marvin's original is a slow, meditative groove ... the bassline walking through the chaos with patience, his voice gentle even in its anguish ... Chaka brings a different kind of energy to the song. Her voice does not ask the question softly. She demands it, her voice rising through the arrangement like a woman who has been asking the same question for too long and is tired of waiting for an answer. The arrangement is built around a driving funk rhythm section, the horns punching harder, the production bigger. Where Marvin was bewildered, Chaka is angry, and the anger is as valid a response to the world's injustices as Marvin's gentle confusion. The question is the same. The tone has shifted.</p>
Chaka Khan
2002

Which Version Speaks to You?

42%
38%
20%

1,203 votes cast

Who else did it better?

The Sunday Drop
One song. One story. Every Sunday.

No algorithms. No trending sections. Just a song someone loved and the story behind it. Delivered Sunday morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

0:00
0:00