Who Did It Better

Three Times a Lady

You're once, twice, three times a lady
And I love you

Three Times a Lady 0:30 counts the ways she matters in his life. Once for who she is. Twice for what she gives. Three times for everything words cannot reach. The repetition is the only way to hold something this big.

One time is not enough. He will keep counting if he has to, because what she means cannot be contained in a single declaration. She deserves to be named more than once.

Original or Cover

The Original -- 1978

The Commodores

The Commodores

A declaration of love measured in increments of time. The Commodores recorded it as a ballad built around Lionel Richie's gentle vocal and a melody that became one of the most recognizable of the 70s. he is trying to explain the depth of his devotion by breaking it down into something measurable. Three times a lady... the phrase is his attempt to capture a quality that language cannot really hold. simple, sincere, and so effective that it became a wedding standard almost immediately after its release.

That same declaration gets a Luther Vandross treatment on his 1994 album *Songs*. Where Lionel's original is gentle and unadorned ... his voice carrying the melody with the kind of lightness that made him a star ... Luther approaches the song with the full range of his instrument. The tempo is slower, the arrangement more elaborate, the vocal runs more intricate. Luther's voice does not float the way Lionel's did. It builds, layer by layer, climbing toward the final chorus with the kind of controlled power that only a master vocalist can summon. Where Lionel sang three times a lady as a simple observation, Luther sings it as a verdict reached after careful consideration. The conclusion is the same. The deliberation is what makes it hit.

Floating Player

The Cover -- 1994

Luther Vandross

Luther Vandross

Luther Vandross struggled with diabetes and died from complications in 2005. His album Dance with My Father won four Grammys posthumously.

Floating Player
The Sunday Drop
One song. One story. Every Sunday.

No algorithms. No trending sections. Just a song someone loved and the story behind it. Delivered Sunday morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Image Credits

1,414 artist portraits across 5 genres (Rock, Jazz, Soul, Blues, Folk). 1,363 sourced from Wikipedia (Creative Commons / Public Domain), 50 from Deezer (promotional artwork).

Full attribution breakdown →

Who Did It Better

Three Times a Lady

Written by Lionel Richie

You're once, twice, three times a lady
And I love you

This song is about...

A declaration of love measured in increments of time. The Commodores recorded it as a ballad built around Lionel Richie's gentle vocal and a melody that became one of the most recognizable of the 70s. he is trying to explain the depth of his devotion by breaking it down into something measurable. Three times a lady... the phrase is his attempt to capture a quality that language cannot really hold. simple, sincere, and so effective that it became a wedding standard almost immediately after its release.

That same declaration gets a

The Commodores or Luther
Luther Vandross treatment on his 1994 album *Songs*. Where Lionel's original is gentle and unadorned ... his voice carrying the melody with the kind of lightness that made him a star ... Luther approaches the song with the full range of his instrument. The tempo is slower, the arrangement more elaborate, the vocal runs more intricate. Luther's voice does not float the way Lionel's did. It builds, layer by layer, climbing toward the final chorus with the kind of controlled power that only a master vocalist can summon. Where Lionel sang three times a lady as a simple observation, Luther sings it as a verdict reached after careful consideration. The conclusion is the same. The deliberation is what makes it hit.</p>
Luther Vandross struggled with diabetes and died from complications in 2005. His album Dance with My Father won four Grammys posthumously.

Which Version Speaks to You?

42%
38%
20%

1,203 votes cast

Who else did it better?

The Sunday Drop
One song. One story. Every Sunday.

No algorithms. No trending sections. Just a song someone loved and the story behind it. Delivered Sunday morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

0:00
0:00