Who Did It Better

Marvin OR The Temptations?

Marvin Gaye Marvin Gaye 1962

Stubborn Kind of Fellow

Written by Marvin Gaye, William 'Mickey' Stevenson, George Gordy

I'm a stubborn kind of fellow
Got a will of my own

What's this song about ↓

the kind of love that arrives without warning and refuses to be ignored. Marvin Gaye recorded it as an early hit, a song about a woman so persistent in her affection that he finally gives in. The title says it all: he is a stubborn kind of fellow, resistant to love, but she is stubborn too. a battle of wills where both sides win. The arrangement is pure early Motown: handclaps, horns, a rhythm section that drives the song forward with the kind of energy that only young musicians can generate.

That same stubborn love gets a different kind of energy from the Temptations in their 1969 version. Where Marvin's original is an uptempo soul workout, his voice young and eager, the Temptations bring their trademark harmonies and a slicker production. The tempo is slightly slower, the arrangement more polished, the vocals more layered. Where Marvin sounded like a man being won over in real time, the Temptations sound like a group of men reflecting on the experience of being won over, their harmonies suggesting that this is a story they have all lived. The song becomes less about one man's surrender and more about a universal truth: love finds a way around even the most stubborn resistance.

The Temptations The Temptations 1969

Variation A — side column

Marvin Gaye 1962
The Temptations 1969

I already know

Play me a sample

Marvin The Temptations

I need to be convinced

Variation B — left & right edges

Marvin Gaye 1962

I already know

Play me a sample

Marvin The Temptations

I need to be convinced

The Temptations 1969

Variation C — filled color-coded buttons

Marvin Gaye 1962
The Temptations 1969

I already know

Play me a sample

Marvin The Temptations

I need to be convinced

The Sunday Drop
One song. One story. Every Sunday.

No algorithms. No trending sections. Just a song someone loved and the story behind it. Delivered Sunday morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Image Credits

1,414 artist portraits across 5 genres (Rock, Jazz, Soul, Blues, Folk). 1,363 sourced from Wikipedia (Creative Commons / Public Domain), 50 from Deezer (promotional artwork).

Full attribution breakdown →

Who Did It Better

Marvin OR The Temptations?

Marvin Gaye Marvin Gaye 1962
The Temptations The Temptations 1969

Stubborn Kind of Fellow

Written by Marvin Gaye, William 'Mickey' Stevenson, George Gordy

I'm a stubborn kind of fellow
Got a will of my own

What's this song about ↓

the kind of love that arrives without warning and refuses to be ignored. Marvin Gaye recorded it as an early hit, a song about a woman so persistent in her affection that he finally gives in. The title says it all: he is a stubborn kind of fellow, resistant to love, but she is stubborn too. a battle of wills where both sides win. The arrangement is pure early Motown: handclaps, horns, a rhythm section that drives the song forward with the kind of energy that only young musicians can generate.

That same stubborn love gets a different kind of energy from the Temptations in their 1969 version. Where Marvin's original is an uptempo soul workout, his voice young and eager, the Temptations bring their trademark harmonies and a slicker production. The tempo is slightly slower, the arrangement more polished, the vocals more layered. Where Marvin sounded like a man being won over in real time, the Temptations sound like a group of men reflecting on the experience of being won over, their harmonies suggesting that this is a story they have all lived. The song becomes less about one man's surrender and more about a universal truth: love finds a way around even the most stubborn resistance.

Variation A — side column

Marvin Gaye 1962
The Temptations 1969

I already know

Play me a sample

Marvin The Temptations

I need to be convinced

Variation B — left & right edges

Marvin Gaye 1962

I already know

Play me a sample

Marvin The Temptations

I need to be convinced

The Temptations 1969

Variation C — filled color-coded buttons

Marvin Gaye 1962
The Temptations 1969

I already know

Play me a sample

Marvin The Temptations

I need to be convinced

The Sunday Drop
One song. One story. Every Sunday.

No algorithms. No trending sections. Just a song someone loved and the story behind it. Delivered Sunday morning.

Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

0:00
0:00